The Livabl forums are closed to new posts and replies.
Read more about this here.
 
Change Location
 
DIANA KRIKUNEZ
Buzzer
reply 38
 

Quartz vs. Granite...Which would you choose for a small uptown condo?

I'm renovating my client's small condo and debating between granite and quartz:

- We want to keep it light and modern. Granite countertops are all very busy looking (other than black ones), versus the consistency of quartz.

- The client will stay in this condo for years to come; however it seems granite sells better than quartz in resale (yet they're comparably priced)

- In terms of maintenance - that's a non-issue since quartz requires none and granite does (but it's a simple process)
22
General Chit-Chat
 
 
 
RYAN MCGOVERN
Senior Buzzer
reply 642 vote 117
 
 
4 BEST REPLY
I worked in the stone and tile industry, and I would much rather have a quartz countertop than granite. There is a tonne of garbage imported granite being used nowadays, but at the end of the day you pay for what you get. I've heard horror stories of people choosing a polished black granite countertop, and then finding out that it was actually dyed black when they put down a hot coffee cup and it left a permanent mark. Economically, for a developer, it would make more sense for granite countertops as there are savings to be had in buying in bulk.

If I had a choice, I would actually go with limestone. There is a great quarry up in Owen Sound that produces some of the nicest looking limestone in the world. Unfortunately, I don't think they would be able to mass produce for a 200+ unit condo, but for smaller boutique projects it would be a great option. This would also give developers a better chance at getting LEED credits, as it is locally sourced.

 
 
 
CARMEN DRAGOMIR
Buzzer
reply 28 vote 3
 
 
1
I think the reason granite may sell better than quartz is because the benefits of quartz are not marketed well to the prospective buyers and in some cases the wrong quartz color and texture are used. Not to mention that quartz is a man made material hence more eco friendly.
With the right combination countertop/cabinet doors/backsplash design both materials should sell that kitchen equally and with the right buyers you may get more for quartz :)
 
 
DIANA KRIKUNEZ
Buzzer
reply 38
 
 
Cool thanks for the feedback Carmen :)
 
 
CARMEN DRAGOMIR
Buzzer
reply 28 vote 3
 
 
you're welcome Diana :)
 
 
BRIAN ELIZABETH
Buzzer
reply 166 vote 10
 
 
Is granite just a fad? Everything I read seems to point to quartz:
- Granite countertops are more porous than quartz.
- Granite countertops are more vulnerable to staining than quartz.
- Granite countertops are less resistant to growth of bacteria.
- Granite countertops are not available in a uniform color surface while quartz countertops are.
- Granite countertops add more value to the overall furniture in the house.
But, granite is really cool because it is all natural... from the earth, then polished.. quartz is rock with human-made materials..
The again, I think cement countertops are really cool!
 
 
ROY BHANDARI
Senior Buzzer
reply 512 vote 60
 
 
Natural products will always win.
Hardwood Floor > Laminate
Granite = Marble = Travertine > Ceramics
Granite > Quartz > Laminate
 
 
ANONYMOUS
BabbleBee
reply 301 vote 23
 
 
I agree with Roy - natural is the winner.
btw, Brian says "cement countertops are really cool" is this a joke?
 
 
BRIAN ELIZABETH
Buzzer
reply 166 vote 10
 
 
Cliff said:
btw, Brian says "cement countertops are really cool" is this a joke?

It is not a joke at all. You can do amazing shapes and there are no edges where slabs meet.
Check out these pictures: http://www.concretenetwork.com/photo-gallery/concrete-countertops_2/
 
 
MELANIE PEDERSON
NewBee
reply 7
 
 
I am a big fan of the Quartz! Particularly Silestone. At work (I work for a local real estate developer), we've been using Silestone for years instead of Granite, and all of our clients rave about it! I've also had Silestone in my townhouse and love the durability and consistency of it. I personally feel that it gives a kitchen a cleaner/sleeker feel. In my new house, we just reno'd the kitchen and used granite ( only because we were on a budget & couldn't afford the Silestone =( ) and although it still looks nice, one of the things that bugs me is that there are "flaws" in the stone. For example, we've used a nice rich grey coloured granite which has black flecks in it. However, there are many bronze/copper marks in the stone - of course because it's a natural stone, but it throws off the colour, and we had no way of foreseeing how many of those marks there would be.

As for Brian - I looked at your link and I do agree that the cement is also really cool! Thanks for sharing that.
 
 
CARMEN DRAGOMIR
Buzzer
reply 28 vote 3
 
 
If granite sells better the quartz- that's for real estate professionals to answer :)

Which one looks better? it is simply a choice, both can look really good with the right design or awful with the wrong design.

Which one is more practical? Quartz requires almost zero maintenance, granite or any other natural stone needs to be sealed, how often? it depends on how you maintain it.

Cement countertops- extremely versatile, unique look, very trendy especially for lofts with exposed concrete ceiling/columns.
 
 
ROY BHANDARI
Senior Buzzer
reply 512 vote 60
 
 
Is it just me or do those concrete countertops look freaking SWEET??!!
 
 
BRIAN ELIZABETH
Buzzer
reply 166 vote 10
 
 
Cliff: You wrote:
Cliff said:
btw, Brian says "cement countertops are really cool" is this a joke?

Obviously, I was not joking! Just check out what Roy said:
Roy said:
Is it just me or do those concrete countertops look freaking SWEET??!!

Concrete or cement countertops are amazing. I am surprised that Canada has not seen more of them in "loft" buildings.
I should note that while I love the way they look, I know nothing about them in terms of durability, aversion to stains... and practicality. Anyone have any experience with them?
 
 
SAYF HASSAN
Buzzer
reply 13 vote 3
 
 
1
On a purely aesthetic level, concrete countertops are stunning. No two countertops look exactly the same, they can be stained a variety of colors and textures and polished as well.
On a practical level, they require spills to be cleaned almost immediately. Stain-resistant sealants are not particularly
effective since concrete is such a porous material. It ages and can develop a quite attractive patina over time.
Cost is another factor. Concrete countertops cost roughly $60/sq.ft. Quartz is considerably less.
Personally, I'd go concrete if I was doing the condo for myself. Quartz if I was doing it for a client.
 
 
BRENT WILKER
Buzzer
reply 126 vote 4
 
 
I have personally had both Quartz and Granite; my choice would be Quartz due to less maintenance and more eco-friendly.
 
 
ANONYMOUS
BabbleBee
reply 301 vote 23
 
 
Hello everybody, I don't understand why Quartz would be more eco friendly than Granite. From my understanding granite is natural - you kind of just take the rock, chisel/polish it and slap it on your counter.
Quartz on the other hand is also natural but requires greater processing before its ready for the counter. Surely, all this processing can't be good for the environment?
 
 
DIANA KRIKUNEZ
Buzzer
reply 38
 
 
Good point Cliff...
 
 
BAZIS
NewBee
reply 1 vote 1
 
 
1
Excellent debate! We also discussed this topic on our blog yesterday: http://bit.ly/RoJZfP 

We came to the conclusion that although both have their pros and cons, the calmer less busy look of quartz and its ease of maintenance makes it a great choice for the long run.
 
 
ALLEN
Buzzer
reply 192 vote 54
 
 
1

I had a concrete counter in a previous home I loved it. Looks modern and is durable. It just requires some maintenance to seal the surface, but no more than marble or granite. I had recycled aluminum shavings mixed into the concrete which created a vey subtle sparkle to it.

I much prefer quartz or granite for many reasons. Granite is expected in a higher end kitchen by everyone and I personally think it is overrated and the speckled look gives it a dated appearance.

Advantages of Quartz
- Made of recycled content and does not deplete as much energy and resources as granite. Quarries are destructive to the environment and rock extraction is a very labourous and energy consuming process. Transport of granite, often overseas, also requires a lot of energy. 
- Does not require sealing.
- Surface is antimicrobial.
- Seamless/invisible seams.
- Colour and pattern is consistant.
- Some granites emit radon gas.
- Granite has a small chance of cracking, depending on quality and cuts.
- You could get the same look of granite with quartz if you wanted to.

 
 
L.S
NewBee
reply 3
 
 
Quartz is consistent in colour and safe, but granite adds a new dimension as it is natural.  It's like art - no 2 pieces alike and some are Amazing !   Take a look at other natural items like onyz, limestone, etc.    Olympia Tile now has a huge slab showroom, right around the corner from their tile place at Lawrence  and Dufferin.     Over 450 colours of granite, quartz etc.   www.olympiatile.com
 
 
AAREAS INTERACTIVE INC
Buzzer
reply 48 vote 2
 
 
@Melanie Pederson

The 'flaws and flecks' in granite are what it is all about those are what you want. Those are what give it is beauty.
 
 
BETHJACKSON
NewBee
reply 1
 
 
Quartz countertops are just as strong as granite but have the added benefit of being more flexible.  Quartz is also less expensive and the color consistency is really key with quartz. Granite is not consistent and in many cases has several different changes of color. You can place hot pots on the surface but stains do not absorb easily into quartz. I found my quartz slab through my fabricator at Web Don (http://www.web-don.com/our-products/hard-surface-countertops/)- it is just amazing. I would never go back to Granite after having Quartz. 
 
 
JAMES BOMBALES
Buzzer
reply 90 vote 12
 
 
@bethjackson in your experience, did you find quartz to be significantly less expensive than granite? When I was choosing counters from my builder, the quartz options were usually a more expensive upgrade than the granite.
 
 
 
Follow

Search

Search Conversations:

 

Check These Out

The Reserves at Storyrock, House

The Reserves at Storyrock

www.sheahomes.com

House

13141 E Buckskin Trail Scottsdale Arizona

From $1,749,990 To $2,988,545

 
Heritage Ridge, House

Heritage Ridge

www.ahoconstruction.com

House

12701 NE 64th Ave Vancouver Washington

From $607,830 To $695,900